09 Jul Could Knee Surgery Be Placebo?
Arthroscopic debridement and lavage of the knee is often performed on people suffering with knee pain and disability associated with knee osteoarthritis. Moseley and O’ Malley executed a study in 2002 that was quite revealing. The authors start by stating this surgery is often performed when medical and drug therapy fail and that well over 650,000 of these types of operations were performed in the USA annually with each costing much more than $5,000 (at that time). 50% reported pain improvement post operatively. This ratio must also be measured within the wider context of the cost, pain, disability, time off work and similar 8–12-week physiotherapy and rehabilitation required anyway with these operations.
The exact reason why or how this operation works is ‘unclear’ aside from the often used “cleaning out”. It could be that this produces a dramatic, but temporary, change in the already required and fantastic osmotic balance of immune cells, electrolytes, hormones and fluid concentration in the synovium and adjacent tissues. Could it be argued that this quite threatening procedure increases pain in the short term and kickstarts a biological response to being the physiological state back to ‘normality’? ‘Who cares?’ some might say if the result is the result. Except it isn’t, at least half the time. Is the post-operative rehabilitation what helps the knee? Would more than 50% of people who just rehabilitate the knee without surgery improve and without the cost and disability? Is physiotherapy trusted as much as the surgeon? Is movement and exercise and rehabilitation better than rest, immobility and constantly increasing medications? Just some thoughts.
There is no research to say the initial causative degeneration decreases after surgery. There is no research to show local inflammation is reset and downgraded with surgery. There is no research to show the amount of ‘debris’ in the knee directly correlates to the symptoms. There is no research to show inflammatory markers in the synovium directly correlate to symptoms.
More to follow!